@ The Liquid Room, Edinburgh, 17/08/08
Support band Jesus H Foxx don’t make much effort to impress with showmanship and simply focus on their tunes. To be fair you can understand it, as the musical complexity of their songs must require a fair amount of concentration to pull off. Odd time signature changes are thrown into their frenetic beats and propulsive rhythms and clever, often discordant guitar parts are laid down over playful bass lines.
Comparisons with the likes of Talking Heads, and Pavement are justified, and on songs like ‘Tight Ideas’ they also seem to be tapping a similar indie-dance vein as The Rapture. However, the erratic vocal style of their singer irks somewhat. While the vocals are probably intended to suite the jerky quality of the band’s music, you can’t help but wonder what they’d sound like if the singer made more of a concerted effort at being melodic.
There’s a palpable air of excitement tonight as Broken Records take the stage. The hype has been building very nicely for the band of late, with industry types and the music press foaming at the mouth over their commercial potential. Broken Records might be the hottest unsigned band in Britain right now but they carry the weight of expectation very well.
The band’s seven-strong line-up results in a rich, expansive, sound that fills up the liquid rooms with ease. There’s no denying that much of Broken Records’ appeal lies in the way they utilize instruments associated with traditional folk music in a fresh and exciting way. Violins, accordions and ukuleles are all used in their sweeping, bold arrangements, immediately setting them apart from the guitar-orientated songwriting of most indie bands.
However while its tempting to focus on the band’s folky-leanings and draw lazy comparisons with the Arcade Fire, it would do them a disservice. Songs like ‘If the News Makes You Sad, Don’t Watch It’ have the strength and depth to stand up to repeated listens, long after the novelty of the violins wears off. For all the interesting instrumentation, it’s the superb vocals of Jamie Sutherland that really adds something special to the Broken Records sound.
It’s also apparent the band are as interesting lyrically as they are musically. ‘If Eilert Lovborg Wrote a Song’, one of the band’ s most enchanting numbers, is about a character in a 19th century Norwegian play by Henrik Ibsen. Willfully obscure? Perhaps. A rollicking good tune? Absolutely!
‘A Good Reason’ , the band’s folk-infused take on punk rock, gets the sweat flying in the crowd before they wrap-up with the sublime ‘Slow Parade’. It’s hard to imagine a more majestic, grandiose or apt closing. During the set Jamie, the singer, mentioned between songs that their management think they “need a single”. There can only be two possible explanations; they haven’t heard ‘Slow Parade’ or they’re tone deaf.
You can also check out this review on the website 'Real Buzz'
http://www.realbuzz.com/en-gb/Broken_Records%2C_The_Liquid_Rooms%2C_Edinburgh/index?pageID=18774